Skip to content

Psychodynamic vs Psychoanalysis: A Comprehensive Comparison

Psychodynamic Therapy and Psychoanalysis are ways to help people with their thoughts and feelings. They both started with Sigmund Freud a long time ago. The main goal is to understand how our minds work and figure out why we feel upset. Even though they started together, they have changed in different ways over the years to help different people. This article will compare them, looking at where they came from, what they believe, the methods they use, and how they help people today.


Psychoanalysis began with a clever person named Sigmund Freud. He had new and important ideas that became the basis for modern therapy. Freud talked about how our minds have a secret part called the unconscious, and things from our childhood can affect us. In 1899, he wrote a big book called “The Interpretation of Dreams” to explain the main ideas of psychoanalysis. Other smart people like Carl Jung and Alfred Adler joined in and made psychoanalysis more popular, adapting it to help more people.

Psychodynamic Therapy

Psychodynamic therapy is like a bigger group that includes ideas from psychoanalysis. As time passed, people started questioning and changing some things about psychoanalysis. Psychodynamic therapy became larger and included many different ideas from other smart people like Erik Erikson, Melanie Klein, and those who talked about relationships between people (object relations theorists). It’s like a mix of different thoughts that expanded beyond what Freud first said, making therapy more diverse and helpful for different people.

Psychodynamic Therapy and Psychoanalysis

Key Principles

  1. Psychoanalysis:
    • Unconscious Mind: Psychoanalysis believes our minds have a hidden part called the unconscious that affects how we behave. The person who started this, Freud, said there are hidden problems and memories in the unconscious that can change how we think, feel, and act.
    • Free Association and Dream Analysis: Psychoanalysis uses two cool methods to understand the unconscious. One is free association, where you say whatever comes to your mind without stopping. The other is dream analysis, where therapists help you understand what your dreams mean. These methods try to find hidden meanings and problems from the unconscious, like solving a puzzle.
  2. Psychodynamic Therapy:
    • Broader Theoretical Integration: Psychodynamic therapy is like a big umbrella that includes many ideas, not just from Freud. It looks at how we connect with others, how we form relationships, and how things from when we were little affect how we are now. It’s like combining different pieces of knowledge to understand people better.
    • Focus on Current Relationships: Unlike focusing a lot on the past, psychodynamic therapy looks at how we interact with people right now. It wants to improve how we get along with others today. For example, if someone has trouble trusting others because of something that happened when they were a kid, psychodynamic therapy would explore this and try to make it better for them now. It’s like looking at how old patterns affect current friendships and relationships.

Related Article: Transference And Countertransference In Psychotherapy

Therapies involved

  1. Psychoanalysis:
    • Frequency and Duration: Psychoanalysis is like a deep dive into understanding ourselves. People doing this kind of therapy usually meet with their therapist many times each week, and this can go on for a few years. Having frequent and long sessions helps to really explore the hidden parts of the mind and understand what’s going on deep inside.
    • Transference and Countertransference: In psychoanalysis, therapists pay close attention to two tricky things: transference and countertransference. Transference is when you start feeling things about the therapist that really come from your past, and countertransference is when the therapist starts feeling things about you. These feelings give important clues about what’s happening inside your mind.
  2. Psychodynamic Therapy:
    • Variable Session Frequency: Psychodynamic therapy is more flexible. You might meet with your therapist once a week, or maybe even less often. This flexibility is good because different people have different needs and schedules. You can still get a lot of help, even if you don’t meet as often.
    • Interpersonal Exploration: Psychodynamic therapy is like looking at how you get along with others. It’s not just about what happened in the past; it’s also about how your past affects your relationships now. You talk about how you interact with people today and try to understand why certain patterns happen. It’s like looking in a mirror to see how you relate to others and figuring out how to make things better.

How Psychodynamic Approaches are Applied Today

  1. Psychoanalysis:
    • Niche Popularity: Psychoanalysis is not very common. It’s like a special kind of therapy that some people like because it helps them really understand themselves. But not many choose it because it takes a lot of time and can be expensive.
    • Integration with Other Approaches: Some smart therapists mix psychoanalysis with other shorter types of therapy. This way, more people can benefit from the deep ideas of psychoanalysis. It’s like combining the best parts to make it work for more people.
  2. Psychodynamic Therapy:
    • Wide Accessibility: Psychodynamic therapy is like therapy for everyone. It’s flexible and can be found in many places like private practices, clinics, and hospitals. This makes it easier for more people to get help, no matter where they are.
    • Brief and Time-Limited Approaches: Psychodynamic therapy can also be quick and focused. Therapists changed it to fit modern life by offering shorter sessions that look at specific issues. Even though it’s quicker, it still uses the important ideas from psychodynamic therapy to help people with their problems. It’s like getting the best of both worlds—quick and effective.

Discover More: Men’s Mental Health Month – Wellness For Men

In the end, psychodynamic therapy and psychoanalysis, both started by Sigmund Freud, have a long and important history. While psychoanalysis is a special and in-depth kind of therapy, psychodynamic therapy has changed to include more ideas and be more flexible and easy to get. Both ways want to understand the deep parts of our minds, giving people helpful insights and a way to grow and heal. The choice between them depends on what someone likes, what they want to achieve in therapy, and the kinds of problems they need help with. Top of Form

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *